Survey of the Letters of Paul: 1 Timothy 1:4
1 Timothy 1:4Neither give heed to fables - That
is, that they should not bestow their attention on
fables, or regard such trifles as of importance. The
“fables” here referred to were probably the idle and
puerile [pyr' er-al] superstitions [immature;
childish] and conceits of the Jewish rabbies.
The word rendered “fable” (μῦθος muthos)
means properly “speech” or “discourse,” and then
fable or fiction, or a mystic discourse. Such things
abounded among the Greeks as well as the Jews, but
it is probable that the latter here are particularly
intended. These were composed of frivolous and
unfounded stories, which they regarded as of great
importance, and which they seem to have desired to
incorporate with the teachings of Christianity.
Paul, who had been brought up amidst these
superstitions, saw at once how they would tend to
draw off the mind from the truth, and would corrupt
the true religion. One of the most successful arts
of the adversary of souls has been to mingle fable
with truth; and when he cannot overthrow the truth
by direct opposition, to neutralize it by mingling
with it much that is false and frivolous. ~Barnes
Notes
This all harkens back to my sermon, "Affinity"
about kinship and James 1:27. Quoting from
that sermon:
James 1:27---this verse in our
doctrine Fellowship with the Brethren [Pure religion] The phrase "pure religion" means that which is genuine and sincere, or which is free from any improper mixture.
[And
undefiled before God and the Father]
That which God sees to be pure and
undefiled. |
The Adam Clarke commentary says...
Neither give heed to fables - Idle fancies; things
of no moment; doctrines and opinions
unauthenticated; silly legends, of which no people
ever possessed a greater stock than the Jews. Their
Talmud abounds with them; and the English reader may
find them in abundance in Stehlin’s Jewish
Traditions, 2 vols. 8vo. ~Adam Clarke commentary
And endless genealogies - This also refers to Jewish
teaching. The Hebrews kept careful genealogical
records, for this was necessary in order that the
distinction of their tribes might be kept up. Of
course, in the lapse of centuries these tables would
become very numerous, complicated, and extended - so
that they might without much exaggeration be called
“endless.” The Jews attached great importance to
them, and insisted on their being carefully
preserved. As the Messiah, however, had now come -
as the Jewish polity [organized society] was
to cease - as the separation between them and the
pagan was no longer necessary, and the distinction
of tribes was now useless, there was no propriety
that these distinctions should be regarded by
Christians. The whole system was, moreover, contrary
to the genius [distinctive character] of
Christianity, for it served to keep up the pride of
blood and of birth. ~Barnes Notes
Which minister questions - Which afford matter for
troublesome and angry debates. It was often
difficult to settle or understand them. They became
complicated and perplexing. Nothing is more
difficult than to unravel an extensive genealogical
table. To do this, therefore, would often give rise
to contentions, and when settled, would give rise
still further to questions about rank and
precedence. ~Barnes Notes
Rather than godly edifying which is in faith - These
inquiries do nothing to promote true religion in the
soul. They settle no permanent principle of truth;
they determine nothing that is really concerned in
the salvation of people. They might be pursued
through life, and not one soul be converted by them;
they might be settled with the greatest accuracy,
and yet not one heart be made better. Is not this
still true of many controversies and logomachies [la
gom e kes--disputes about words] in the church?
No point of controversy is worth much trouble,
which, if it were settled one way or the other,
would not tend to convert the soul from sin, or to
establish some important principle in promoting true
religion. “So do.” These words are supplied by our
translators, but they are necessary to the sense.
The meaning is, that Timothy was to remain at
Ephesus, and faithfully perform the duty which he
had been left there to discharge. ~Barnes Notes
Now from the Adam Clarke commentary...
Rather than godly edifying - Such discussions as
these had no tendency to promote piety [religious
devotion and reverence to God]. Many, no doubt,
employed much of that time in inquiring who were
their ancestors, which they should have spent in
obtaining that grace by which, being born from
above, they might have become the sons and daughters
of God Almighty.
What had Jewish genealogies to do with the Gospel?
Men were not to be saved by virtue of the privileges
or piety of their ancestors. The Jews depended much
on this. We have Abraham to our father imposed
silence on every check of conscience, and every
godly reproof which they received for their
profligacy [prof la ga cy - abandoned in moral
principle] - unbelief. In the dispensation of
God, Faith in Christ Jesus was the only means and
way of salvation. These endless and uncertain
genealogies produced no faith; indeed they were
intended as a substitute for it; for those who were
intent on making out their genealogical descent paid
little attention to faith in Christ. They ministered
questions rather than that economy of God which is
by faith. This dispensation, says the apostle, is by
faith, οικονομιαν Θεου την εν πιστει· It was not by
natural descent, nor by works, but by faith in
Christ; therefore it was necessary that the people
who were seeking salvation in any other way should
be strictly informed that all their toil and labor
would be vain. ~Adam Clarke commentary
And finally, the John Gill on this same
phrase...
rather than godly edifying, which is in faith - and
which is the principal end of preaching, hearing,
and conversation; and that may be called "godly
edifying, or the edification of God", as it may be
rendered, which he is the author of, and which he
approves of, and is by, and according to his word;
or that in which souls are built up an habitation
for God, and are built up in faith and holiness, and
by an increase of every grace: and this is "in
faith", not only in the grace of faith, but by the
doctrine of faith, on which the saints may build one
another, and by which they are edified through the
faithful ministration of it by the ministers of the
word; when fabulous stories and disputes, about
genealogies, are useless and unedifying: not that
the apostle condemns all genealogies, such as we
have in the writings of the Old Testament, and in
the evangelists, nor all inquiries into them, and
study of them, which, rightly to settle, is in some
cases of great importance and use, but the private
and unprofitable ones before mentioned. Some copies
read, "the dispensation of God, which is in faith";
meaning the dispensation of the mysteries of grace,
which are in the doctrine of faith, which becomes a
faithful steward of them, and not fables and
genealogies, which issue in questions, quarrels, and
contentions. ~John Gill commentary