Twenty-First
Century Crusades?
by Chris Cumming
Beginning May 2nd of this year [2005], the new Ridley Scott movie,
“Kingdom of Heaven” depicting the twelfth-century Crusades was released in no
less that 54 countries covering Europe, the Middle and Far East. In the few
short weeks since this release, there have been published a number of books,
news articles and editorial pieces covering both the movie and the impact of
crusades on current events. Just what do we know about the Crusades? What was
their purpose? Who instigated them? What prompted these military actions? Who
was affected? How are the crusades linked to events we see unfolding today in
both Europe and the Middle East?
Could we see twenty-first century crusades in the near future that will mimic
those crusades of almost 1,000 years ago? Could this be the incident that will
fulfill the key prophetic event of armies around Jerusalem we read of in Luke
21:20: And when ye shall see Jerusalem compassed with armies, then know that
the desolation thereof is nigh.
Reasons for the Crusades
The most immediate cause for the Crusades was Muslim incursions into previously
Christian lands. The crusades were mainly directed toward Jerusalem and the
Christian shrine of the Holy Sepulcher. In the movie, we see 200,000 Muslim
warriors surrounding and overcoming Jerusalem. The Catholic Church in Western
Europe fought the Crusades against heretics or in other words, Muslims because
their belief differed from that of the official church. At this time in Europe
was a feudal society controlled by the monarchy, clergy and the knights. The
church had the utmost authority. The Pope was the head of the church and
carried the most religious and political power and influence over the land. The
Crusades were part of the church’s wish to expand its empire.
The Pope was able to grip the whole of Europe with “Crusade Fever”. Part of his
propaganda was to attack the authenticity of the Qur’an and the Prophet
Muhammad, who were both tagged imposters, sorcery, evil, satanic and pagan. The
church actually had citizens believing they could pay their penance for their
sins by going off and slaughtering believers of other religions. History
records at least nine crusades during the 11th, 12th and
13th centuries. Several see direct linkage between those crusades
and current events affecting most of the world.
Today’s Events Seeded by Crusades
In a recent article in the Los Angeles Times, “Blame
the Crusades”, they begin by speaking of the movie itself. “From swords to
suicide bombers, the West’s relationship with the Middle East hasn’t changed
much in the past millennium. That’s why the film, ‘Kingdom of Heaven’ struck
such a chord. It rams home the notion that events during the Crusades eerily
parallel current world affairs. The movie ends by noting that in modern times
there is again conflict in the Middle East. That misses the point. The
Crusades aren’t just a true-life allegory of current world conflicts. In
various ways, they’re a major part of the reason those conflicts exist.”
Later in the article one reads, “The crusades created a mind-set in which Muslim
presence would not be tolerated in Europe, which played out violently when Spain
expelled its Muslims in 1492. Popes had long exhorted European Christians to
sever all relations with Muslims, a call that echoes to this day. Newly elected
Pope Benedict XVI opposes allowing Turkey into the European Union, saying it
runs counter to history; he also deplores European multiculturalism as ‘fleeing
from what is one’s own.’” Will these events of old be played out again? In his
commentary, Mr. Burkert states:
“Muslim hatred for the European countries and
peoples, who have welcomed them over the past fifty years, may soon bring about
a reaction that will rock the western world.”
“There are indications that the breaking point may
come soon.”
“European Muslims, through their refusal to
assimilate and adopt European customs and traditions, are rapidly setting the
stage for a backlash movement that may well see the majority of Europe’s
indigenous peoples turning against the Muslim foreigners.”
Matein Khalid, a Dubai-based investment banker just published an editorial
piece on the Crusades. In it he says, “The Crusades changed both Europe and
the Middle East and their echoes, nine centuries later, still resonate in Arab
politics.” “The modern Arab world was shaped by the Crusades as surely as the
West was. While the Frankish knights and feudal lords squandered fortunes in
the Holy Land, the kings of Europe became stronger, the genesis of the rise of
the nation state in France that culminated in Louis XIV, Napoleon’s conquest of
Egypt and, later, Algerie Francals. The concept of Arab nationalism was
unthinkable without the Crusades.”
Not just Muslims But Jews
When the Popes across these centuries of the Crusades whipped the populace into
a murderous frenzy, other non-Catholic groups were targeted. Jews were killed
in both Europe and the Middle East. Going back to the LA Times article,
“Crusaders often wondered why, if they were fighting Muslims in far-off lands,
they should leave unmolested other 'infidels' closer to home—Jews. Thus the
Crusades gave rise to the first big waves of violent anti-Semitism in Europe,
which would flare for centuries and eventually feed the Nazi Holocaust. This in
turn gave birth to modern Zionism, seen by Muslims as another European
imperialistic attack.”
Alan Woods in his recent article, “George
W. Bush and the Crusades” quotes the crusaders themselves regarding the
Jews:
“We have set out to march a long way to fight the enemies of God in the East,
and behold, before our very eyes are his worst foes, the Jews. They must be
dealt with first." And again: "You are the descendants of those who killed and
hanged our God. Moreover [God] himself said:
'The day will yet dawn when my children will come and avenge my blood.' We are
his children and it is our task to carry out his vengeance upon you, for you
showed yourselves obstinate and blasphemous towards him ... [God]
has abandoned you and has turned his radiance towards us and has made us his
own.” (N. Cohn, The Pursuit of the Millennium, p. 70.)
Economics and the Crusades
As the Crusades got underway, European merchants saw an opportunity to get rich
by linking up and taking advantage of Middle Eastern trade routes. Clearly
Europe has a strong economic interest in Israel and the Middle East today.
Quoting form the Alan Woods article again:
“The merchants were even more interested in the success of this venture. The
Turks now controlled the lucrative trade routes to the East, like the famous
Silk Road. The most Christian merchants of Venice, Genoa and other European
ports were completely shut out, and they wanted to get a share of the action.
The crusades were their best chance to do this, moreover under the banner of the
Almighty. This was an opportunity not to be missed.”
Recent events have shown us Europe’s keen interest in Middle Eastern oil and
arms trade. As world tensions increase, we will see this repeated and may
include Europe having to interject itself politically and militarily into Israel
and the Middle East.
Twenty-First Century Crusades? -- What to Look For